Pope Francis has described the choice facing U.S. voters in the upcoming presidential election as one between the “lesser of two evils,” criticising both former President Donald Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris for their stances on key issues. Speaking aboard the papal plane on 13 September (14 September Singapore time), the Pope condemned Trump’s anti-migrant policies and Harris’s support for abortion rights, both of which he deemed “against life.”
Background
During the press conference, Pope Francis elaborated on his views, highlighting the Catholic Church’s position on abortion as murder and condemning the act of sending away migrants as a “sin.” The Pope’s comments come at a critical time as Americans prepare to vote in the upcoming election, and his remarks have sparked significant discussion online. A video of the press conference, complete with English translations, has been widely circulated.
Criticism of Trump and Harris
Pope Francis did not mince words when addressing the policies of the two presidential hopefuls. “Both of them are against life,” he stated, pointing out that one “throws out migrants” while the other “kills children.” The Pope’s blunt assessment underscores the Catholic Church’s strong stance on both immigration and abortion, two issues that are highly contentious in U.S. politics.
The Dilemma for Voters
When asked who he considered the lesser of the two evils, Pope Francis admitted, “I don’t know.” He emphasised that American voters would have to make this difficult decision themselves. “Americans voting in this upcoming election will have to make a decision between these two candidates,” he said, leaving the choice to the electorate.
Reactions and Implications
The Pope’s comments have generated a range of reactions, particularly among U.S. Catholics who are grappling with the moral complexities of the upcoming election. Some have praised his forthrightness, while others have criticised him for not offering a clearer directive. The debate over how to reconcile religious beliefs with political choices is likely to intensify as the election approaches.
Historical Context and Future Implications
This is not the first time Pope Francis has weighed in on U.S. politics. In previous instances, he has urged bishops to act as pastors rather than politicians, particularly on the issue of denying Communion to pro-abortion rights politicians. His latest comments are expected to influence the ongoing discourse among American Catholics and could have lasting implications for how religious voters approach future elections.
The Pope’s remarks serve as a stark reminder of the moral and ethical considerations that underpin political decisions, urging voters to reflect deeply on their choices.
