Fathership

OP-ED: Comparing MFA Vivian’s “family quarrel” remark to MSF’s video on domestic violence uncalled for

The ‘family quarrel’ analogy drew ire to the comments on an Instagram post by MSF which had called for people to speak up against domestic violence.

|3 min read
OP-ED: Comparing MFA Vivian’s “family quarrel” remark to MSF’s video on domestic violence uncalled for

Minister Vivian Balakrishnan’s remark earlier this week that the war in Palestine is “a family quarrel, in another family” was hard to swallow. Our humanity is not a switch we can turn off – especially when we are bombarded, day in and day out, with images of grief, death and destruction resulting from the violence in Palestine.

The ‘family quarrel’ analogy drew ire to the comments on an Instagram post by MSF which had called for people to speak up against domestic violence.

MSF’s caption said, “Your intervention can help save lives”.

Yet, we are told by Minister Vivian that the worst thing would be to “get involved unnecessarily” when it came to Palestine.

It felt like a double standard.

In both situations, the moral responsibility to intervene to protect our fellow man weighs heavy on us.

However, there were comments to the post that felt that Minister Vivian’s point that we remain calm, united and constructive was fit for ridicule.

The ‘family quarrel’ analogy had been in poor taste – but it does not make the message that we have to keep together any less salient. The sheer anger and bitterness we saw in the comments show us the need for it.

Ultimately, our adversary is not each other, nor is it the government. Yes, many feel that the government should be doing more, and condemn Israel. (For the record, the government has condemned Israel for having gone too far. Singapore also voted in favour of Palestine’s membership in the United Nations in May. Singapore had abstained on this vote in 2012, so this is a step forward.)

However, the flood of comments to the post had been uncalled for – the post had not touched on the war, and it had wanted to promote a cause that should be viewed no less important than what is happening in Palestine.

Furthermore, it would not hurt us to have a think for those who do not want Singapore to get involved, or even those who might support Israel. We might not agree with them, and we might think that they are wrong – but they are no less Singaporean than us, and are as entitled to demand from the government as we do.

This is what it means to not import quarrels. Yes, there is a ‘quarrel’ in Israel-Palestine. But that does not mean that we have to quarrel here at home. Our views may differ, but we can agree to disagree, and keep together.

Ultimately, our goal is the same, regardless of how we think it can be achieved: durable peace in the Middle East.

(The opinions expressed in this article are the author's own and do not reflect the view of the Editor's)

Read next article ⬇️

Morbi ornare, lorem nec posuere pretium, libero lorem faucibus nisi

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amor.

|2 min read
Morbi ornare, lorem nec posuere pretium, libero lorem faucibus nisi

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Nulla sit amet arcu finibus, ultrices sapien a, vestibulum elit. Maecenas sit amet posuere purus. Maecenas neque odio, vestibulum nec turpis non, pulvinar porta dolor. Morbi quis nisl ex. Ut fringilla eget leo in gravida. Nullam nec lacus eu urna placerat aliquet. Nullam ac rhoncus neque. Nullam eros tellus, ultricies sit amet quam eget, ullamcorper malesuada turpis. Etiam a semper odio, iaculis tristique lectus. Etiam feugiat felis ut ex congue, quis scelerisque velit accumsan. Suspendisse potenti. Praesent dictum risus nisl. Morbi ornare, lorem nec posuere pretium, libero lorem faucibus nisi, vitae tempus enim mauris nec felis. Pellentesque mollis ante quis fermentum pretium. Orci varius natoque penatibus et magnis dis parturient montes, nascetur ridiculus mus. Integer finibus felis eu neque vestibulum, sed gravida ante ornare. Donec non placerat leo. Aenean arcu nisl, finibus quis enim fermentum, pharetra porta metus. Praesent libero tellus, posuere eget sagittis nec, vulputate at lacus. Donec eu ullamcorper justo. Phasellus varius mollis lectus. Duis non iaculis metus, quis tincidunt ligula. Nunc et sem eu nisi sollicitudin pretium non id nisl. Vivamus et lectus placerat, laoreet urna et, aliquet diam. Nam condimentum arcu sit amet arcu blandit cursus. Sed feugiat congue libero ut consequat. Mauris eleifend erat sed hendrerit consectetur. Duis eleifend pellentesque nulla, ut auctor orci aliquam nec. Vestibulum vel lobortis lacus. Duis gravida sagittis quam. Aenean ac ligula id orci aliquam venenatis. Mauris tempus porttitor mauris quis feugiat. Maecenas rhoncus laoreet maximus. Vivamus semper tempus imperdiet. Quisque sodales massa elit, nec ornare lacus varius sed. Sed sit amet sapien dui. Curabitur tincidunt tortor ac malesuada faucibus. Nulla elit turpis, accumsan in purus quis, convallis iaculis arcu. Aliquam dapibus molestie nisl, eu placerat nisi maximus sit amet. Ut lectus lectus, finibus non auctor at, pellentesque nec lorem. Vivamus pellentesque dui a ex imperdiet, eu malesuada mi maximus. Suspendisse potenti. Aliquam aliquam metus lacus, vitae ullamcorper justo pulvinar at. Vivamus sit amet massa sed nunc sagittis blandit. Aenean id mattis leo. Aliquam vel ex sem. Phasellus tempor, lorem sit amet porta lobortis, lorem dolor gravida lacus, non finibus diam lacus vel metus. Proin interdum quis enim ac pulvinar. Quisque vel dolor libero. Sed ac ullamcorper nibh.